Posted: January 16, 2019

Allen's Versus Fireball

Fireball Cinnamon Whisky recently upset the longstanding dominion of Allen's Coffee Brandy in Maine.

Yesterday Bangor Daily News reported that the beloved Allen's Coffee Brandy was dethroned as Maine's top-selling liquor by Fireball Cinnamon Whisky. Allen's Coffee Brandy of Somerville, Massachusetts, is referred to as "The Champagne of Maine" for Mainers' devotion to the liquor as seen in its dominant sales since the 1980s. Until this year, that is. Data released by the Maine Bureau of Alcoholic Beverages and Lottery Operations reveals that this overtaking is largely due to the surge in 50 ml Fireball 'nips' purchases, which accounts for $4 million in sales. Allen's devotees can be reassured that Fireball only beat out Allen's in sales, with the former coming in at $10.1 million in comparison to the latter's which totaled $9.6 million in 2018 sales. This means that per usual, Allen's still dominates the total volume purchased.

Without a doubt, the state is abuzz with the sounds of controversy over this feud. Bangor Daily News poses the question 'Does liking Fireball more than Allen's make you less of a Mainer?' in a running poll to take stock of reactions. The majority of votes suggest 'Yes,' ringing in at 101 Yes votes (58.72%) and 71 No votes (41.28%), which defends the state's pride for Allen's and the fact that Allen's still leads the competition in liquor volume purchased this year. 

Allen's Coffee Brandy, whose logo "hasn't changed one iota in an eon" has typically been an ode to the outdoorsman, the fisherman, cold Mainer or coffee lover. The Portland Press herald attributes the rise in Fireball sales due to an increased popularity in bar shots and the cocktail fad. Some claim that it is time for Allen's to be replaced, while others mourn Fireball's takeover. Regardless of Allen's current second-place standing, it has remained a symbol of Maine, but Fireball might have other plans.

Allen's recipes

Allen's Downeast Hot Mocha

1 oz Allen's Coffee Brandy
3 oz Hot Cocoa

Get The Recipe

Allen's White Russian

1.5 oz Allen's Coffee Flavored Brandy
1.5 oz Vodka
3 oz Milk Or Cream

Get The Recipe

Allen's Coffee-Toffeetini

1 oz Allen's Coffee Brandy
2 oz Butterscotch Schnapps
2 oz Milk

Get The Recipe

fireball recipes

Fireball Tart

1.5 oz Fireball Whisky
1 oz Pomegranate Liqueur
Squeeze of Lemon Juice

Get The Recipe

Drink If You Dairy

1.5 oz Fireball Whisky
1.5 oz Milk
1.5 oz Half & Half
0.25 tsp Powdered Sugar

Get The Recipe


750ML 60 Proof Brandy
$ 11.49


750ML 66 Proof Canadian Whiskey
$ 16.99


A photo of a delicious looking adult beverage as seen from above.
The Maine Spirits App

Discover cocktail recipes you can make with the ingredients you already have on hand! Select your ingredients, and let the Create a Cocktail app match them with our collection of cocktail recipes.

Download the Maine Spirits App in the iTunes App Store  Download the Maine Spirits App in the Google Play Store